National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)
NIH…Turning Discovery Into Health

Información en Español

Health Topics A-Z

Know the Science: The Facts About Health News Stories

Know the Science: The Facts About Health News Stories

What’s Missing: Important Details!

Headline: Chinese herbs equal to Tamiflu in Reducing H1N1 fever: study

A 2011 news story reported on a study comparing the conventional flu medicine Tamiflu, a common Chinese herbal flu product called maxingshigan–yinqiaosan, and the combination of the two.

Compared with no treatment, the combination helped relieve participants’ fevers sooner, the news story explained.

But what was missing from the news story?

Tell me!

What was missing: The story didn’t say that participants’ fevers went down only about 11 hours sooner with the combination of products, which readers may want to know when they’re deciding whether to use the products. The story also didn’t mention that none of the products helped with symptoms such as cough and sore throat.

This page last modified October 18, 2017